Yoder's

A wise person will grab happiness where they can find it.  A really wise person will hop in the car and drive to Yoder’s Restaurant in the Amish community of Pinecraft nestled on Bahia Vista in Sarasota.  Yoder’s is stuffed to the rafters with happiness.  We made what can only be called a pilgrimage to this city block of hallowed ground for a belated birthday dinner after having been thwarted by a line of salivating would-be diners that wound its way out the door and far into the parking lot on our first visit.  You expect lines like this for Rolling Stones concert tickets or a stall in the ladies room anywhere, not for a little Amish restaurant in Florida.  We were soon to find out why.

First of all, if you’re heading to Yoder’s, go hungry and go in the middle of the afternoon.  Any time of the day is fair game for eating in Florida but the normal feeding times 8am, Noon and 5pm will find Yoder’s overflowing.  We went on a Thursday afternoon around 2:30 and still the place was more than half full, a combination of tourists, locals and Pinecraft families.  The restaurant is very homey with lots of pine and lace and Amish art on the walls.  Despite all the people there was an almost reverential hush that presided over us all.  Perhaps it was the effect of tall ladies in dresses and white kapps circulating among the tables like school teachers of old.  Perhaps it was the massive plates of food.

We sat down quite intent on having the fried chicken and pie but our determination was tested when we saw the menu. (Click on the menu link to have a look at the full menu--amazing! It's a pdf file so it may take a minute to load)  Scalloped potatos and ham.  Anna’s Salad  Fresh spring mix, smoked turkey, dried cranberries, mandarin oranges, strawberries,

crumbled gorgonzola cheese and sugared pecans with raspberry vinaigrette dressing.

Served with fruit bread.  Mom’s meatloaf.  Alaskan cod. Manhattan sandwiches.  

And then there were the sides! 

Mashed Potatoes with Gravy

Amish Potato Cakes

Chicken Stuffing

French Fries

Baked Potato (after 4 p.m.)

Baked Sweet Potato (after 4 p.m.)

Corn Cakes

Amish Noodles

5-Bean Salad

Sliced Tomatoes

Tossed Salad

Cole Slaw

Applesauce

Buttered Corn

Green Beans

Vegetable of the Day

Fried Okra

Baked Hot Apples

Corn Muffins

Onion Rings (add $1.00)

Jamie stuck to his guns and ordered the fried half a chicken with Amish potato cakes and cole slaw.  I broke ranks and ordered the crab cakes with onion rings and tossed salad with bleu cheese dressing.  We both had the delicious Amish mint tea to drink.

Lordy, lordy, lordy.  When the waitress returned with our meals we could barely fit it all on the table, let alone see each other over the mountain of fried chicken.  From then on it was pure bliss. As fun as it is to try new cuisines and have dinner plates arrive with food presented as sculpture, there is something innately right about simple food exquisitely prepared.  You really can taste the difference when food comes from a kitchen that is concerned with the entire process of the meal.  Fresh ingredients. Sticklers for quality. Knowledge that good food will bring people back.

Every morsel was fabulous.  The crab cakes rivaled my favorites at Venezia on Long Boat Key, FL and Marie Dixon’s kitchen in South Freeport, ME. The onion rings were the size of bracelets with a batter so light it was akin to tempura. The coleslaw was perfection and the Amish potato cakes left us staring at each other in disbelief:  they arrived with maple syrup.  Fans of potato bread and potato donuts will know immediately how light, tasty and filling a potato pancake could be.  I supposed we were expecting something akin to a latke so when something resembling a pancake arrived with syrup we were on them in an instant. And then there was the chicken.  Truly, words can’t describe it.  Watch this segment from Man vs. Food for an idea of what it’s like to experience Yoder’s chicken.

We purposely ate only half our meals so we could have leftovers and more importantly, so we could have pie.  

Peanut Butter Cream       

Chocolate Peanut Butter    

Coconut Cream

Banana CreamChocolate Cream

Fresh Strawberry

Red Raspberry Cream

Homemade Butterscotch

Pineapple Cream

Florida Key Lime

Traditional in graham crust.

Yoder’s Key Lime

Dutch Apple Crumb

Southern Pecan

Blueberry Crumb

Black Raspberry

Red Raspberry

Shoofly

Chocolate Pecan

Raisin

Strawberry Rhubarb

Rhubarb

Mom’s Egg Custard

Baked Peach

Blackberry

Cherry

Pumpkin

Sugar Free Apple

Sugar Free Blueberry

On our previous visit to Yoder’s marketplace, we had brought home a small chocolate cream pie.  It was glorious and I chose another piece for this visit.  Jamie, a true peanut butter aficionado, went for Yoder’s peanut butter pie, which, if you watched the Man vs. Food footage, you have lovingly described to you in detail.  That pie is simply magical.  Neither too sweet nor too heavy, it’s like eating a fluffy peanut butter cloud.  We could only manage half our slices of pie with our beautiful coffee; thus they were lovingly boxed up and added to the two bags full of leftovers we departed with clutched in our happy little hands.

Some restaurants you go to just to eat something.  Others you go to just to relax. A trip to Yoder’s is a reminder that someone out there loves you.

For more information on the Pinecraft Amish community and the wonder that is Yoder's, read my blog post at Sodding Typical Amish Surprise .

(All photos are from Google images.  We were going to take photos but couldn't hold the cameras and chicken at the same time....)

Sarasota on Dwellable